Brexit Delivered
LatestEU–UK summit, Friday 20 November: what Britain could sign up toAll news

Home / Rejoin

The rejoin reality

Rejoining would mean worse terms than before

The UK left with special terms won over 40 years. A new applicant accepts the EU's rules as they stand today.

Illustration of a container ship being loaded at a British port

The question nobody asks

There is no "rejoin". There is only a new application.

Under Article 49 of the EU Treaty, the UK would apply like any other country. All 27 members must agree the terms, and each has a veto. The old deal is not on the table.

Support for rejoining, as usually asked

55%

Support once the old opt-outs are off the table

35%

43% opposed

The majority disappears when the terms are spelled out

Polls showing a majority for rejoining ask about the EU people remember. When YouGov asked about rejoining without the UK's old exemptions from the euro and passport-free travel, support fell by 20 points and more people opposed it than backed it.

YouGov, June 2026

"You cannot pick and choose among the union's freedoms, nor can you decide to take only what suits you."
Emmanuel Macron, President of France, 30 September 2026
Britain should work towards "rejoining a significantly reformed EU".
Tony Blair, 25 September 2026. Even the leading voice for rejoining is not arguing for the EU as it is today.
Only 18–20%
of people in France and Germany think the UK should return on its old terms. Around 6 in 10 say it must sign up to everything. YouGov, June 2026

The rejoin reality

Rejoining would not bring back the old deal

The UK left with a set of special terms won over 40 years. A new applicant applies under Article 49 of the EU Treaty and accepts the rules as they stand. Here is how the three positions compare.

AreaAs a member, to 2020TodayLikely terms on re-entry
Budget rebate Special deal
The UK rebate, agreed in 1984, returned several billion pounds a year.
UK decides
No membership fee. Only legacy Withdrawal Agreement payments, now under £1bn a year.
Downgrade
The UK rebate no longer exists. Any new correction would need the unanimous agreement of all 27 members.
Currency Special deal
Legal opt-out from the euro (Protocol 15).
UK decides
The pound, with interest rates set by the Bank of England.
Downgrade
New members are legally committed to adopt the euro once they meet the criteria. No new opt-out has been granted since 1992.
Borders and Schengen Special deal
Outside Schengen, with UK passport checks kept (Protocols 19 and 20).
UK decides
UK border checks and visa policy.
Downgrade
The Schengen rules bind all new members (Protocol 19, Article 7), with passport-free travel to follow.
Free movement Applied
EU citizens had the right to live and work in the UK.
UK decides
One points-based system for all countries since 2021.
Returns
Free movement would apply in full. There are no permanent opt-outs.
Voting and vetoes Shared
Most EU laws passed by qualified majority. Vetoes only in areas needing unanimity, such as tax and foreign policy.
UK decides
Parliament votes on UK law alone.
Weaker
Qualified majority voting across most law-making. EU leaders are debating moving more areas, including foreign policy, from unanimity to majority voting.
Justice and home affairs Special deal
Opt-in, case by case (Protocol 21).
UK decides
UK policing and justice law, with agreed co-operation.
Downgrade
No sign that a pick-and-choose opt-in would be offered again.
Shared EU debt None
No common EU borrowing on this scale before 2020.
UK decides
No liability for the Covid recovery fund or later EU borrowing.
New cost
A share of repaying Covid recovery debt until 2058, and of any future joint borrowing.
Trade deals EU-run
Trade policy set by the EU for all members.
UK decides
Independent deals, including CPTPP, Australia, New Zealand and India.
Lost
UK deals would have to be left or handed over to EU control.

"Likely terms" reflect the EU Treaties and the terms accepted by every member that has joined since 1995. Final terms would be set in accession talks, and in practice the timing of euro adoption depends on a country meeting the criteria. Sources: Treaty on European Union Art. 49; TFEU Art. 140; Protocols 15, 19, 20 and 21; House of Commons Library.

What you would give up

Seven things Britain holds today and would hand back

Each of these is yours now. Each would go, by treaty, on the day the UK re-entered.

  1. The pound

    New members commit to adopting the euro. The UK's opt-out ended when it left.

  2. Your interest rates

    In the euro, mortgage and savings rates follow a rate set in Frankfurt for 21 countries, not one set in London for Britain.

  3. Your borders

    The Schengen rules bind every new member. Free movement returns in full, and the points-based system ends for EU citizens.

  4. Your trade deals

    India, Australia, New Zealand and the Pacific partnership. Trade deals are signed by Brussels alone, so the UK's own would end.

  5. The rebate

    Won in 1984, gone in 2020. As Europe's second-largest economy the UK would pay the second-largest bill, estimated by Britain Unbound at £35bn a year and by Stay Out at £39bn gross in 2028, about £750m a week. That would lower the share paid by Germany and France.

  6. A clean balance sheet

    The EU has borrowed hundreds of billions jointly since the UK left. A returning UK would help repay it until 2058. The economist Bob Lyddon estimates rejoining would add about £1 trillion of "shadow" liabilities, such as guarantees and future spending commitments, equal to about a third of UK GDP.

  7. The last word

    EU law would again override Acts of Parliament, with the EU's court in Luxembourg as the final judge.

Picture the road back in

  1. The application. The UK asks to join. All 27 governments must say yes, so each can name its price. Spain has interests in Gibraltar, and France in fishing.
  2. The negotiation. The UK works through 35 chapters of EU law. The question in each is how quickly the UK adopts the rules, not whether.
  3. The bill. Budget payments begin, with no rebate, into a budget planned at almost €2 trillion for 2028–2034.
  4. The handover. UK trade deals are ended. The UK commits to the euro and to the Schengen rules.
  5. The lock. EU law is supreme again, and changing any of it needs agreement from other countries.

This sequence follows the accession process in Article 49 of the EU Treaty and the terms accepted by every country that has joined since 1995. Final terms and timings would be set in negotiation.

Break-even calculator

Would rejoining pay for itself?

The membership bill would be paid from the first day. Any boost to the economy is an estimate, and would take years to arrive. Set both, and see when the Treasury would get its money back.

Illustration of a balance scale with coins on one side and a sapling on the other

Your assumptions

£30bn
2.7%

Published estimates run from a 7% loss to an 8% gain, and all are disputed. A pro-Brexit economist expects rejoining to shrink the economy; the others expect a boost. Either way the effect is assumed to arrive evenly over 15 years.

On these assumptions the Treasury would wait more than 100 years to get its money back. Once the full boost has arrived it gains only £0.3bn a year.

The bill, every year
£30.0bn
Boost needed for the Treasury to break even
2.7%
Extra tax a year, once the full effect arrives
£30.3bn
Treasury's running total after 10 years
−£189bn

The published estimates, on your figure for the bill

Claimed effectWhere it comes fromExtra tax a year, in fullTreasury gain or loss a year, in fullBack in credit
−7%Professor Patrick Minford, a leading pro-Brexit economist
Staying in the single market and customs union (2018)
−£78.6bn−£108.6bnNever
2.2%Frontier Economics, for the pro-EU campaign Best for Britain
A closer deal, not full membership
£24.7bn−£5.3bnNever
4%Office for Budget Responsibility
Its assumption for the cost of leaving
£44.9bn£14.9bnYear 22
6%US National Bureau of Economic Research paper
From a survey of firms
£67.4bn£37.4bnYear 13
8%US National Bureau of Economic Research paper
From comparing the UK with other countries
£89.8bn£59.8bnYear 10

How it works: the bill is the yearly payment, less the share the EU spends in Britain if you tick that box. The economy is £3,034bn (ONS, 2025), and the Treasury collects about 37p of each extra pound in tax (OBR). The effect on the economy, up or down, is assumed to build up evenly over 15 years, the period the OBR uses for the effect of leaving, while the bill is paid in full from year one. Everything is in today's money. For the economy as a whole, as distinct from the Treasury, the bill equals about 1.0% of national income. Not counted: a share of the EU's joint debt, the loss of Britain's own trade deals, and the commitments to the euro and passport-free borders. Each estimate is contested. See where the figures come from and why they are disputed · Sources

Studying this for A-Level Politics? Read the free briefing on the case for retaining Brexit, with 46 sources, or download the PDF.

Growth and the EU today

The EU of 2016 is not the EU of today

The case for rejoining often assumes Europe is still the confident, fast-growing bloc of a decade ago. Its biggest economies have struggled, and its politics have changed.

"The political class continue this debate today as if the Europe we left in 2016 is the Europe of today. It's nothing like the Europe of today."Andrew Neil, BBC Question Time, September 2026 (as reported)

Real GDP growth, cumulative

1.3%UK growth in 2025, fastest of the four
+6.3% vs +1.9%UK vs Germany, Q2 2026 GDP above Q4 2019

Independent trade policy

The UK negotiates for itself, and is the only European member of CPTPP, a bloc covering about 15% of world GDP.

Rules that fit the UK

Parliament can reform regulation for fintech, life sciences, gene editing and insurance without needing 27 countries to agree.

Fisheries and farming

The UK is an independent coastal state and sets its own farm support. Access for EU boats is now negotiated by UK ministers, not set in Brussels.

The EU today

The Europe people remember is not the Europe on offer

The case for going back assumes the EU of 2016: stable, growing and run from the political centre. Since then it has changed in ways that should give anyone pause, whatever their politics.

43.8%

Germany: the AfD's vote in Saxony-Anhalt

In September 2026 the EU-sceptic AfD won a German state election, the strongest result for a party of the far right in any German state since 1945.

Chatham House, Sept 2026

1st

France: National Rally leads the polls

Its candidate is the front-runner for the 2027 presidential election. The party wants to roll back EU powers from the inside.

UK in a Changing Europe, June 2026

€807bn

Joint EU debt, a first

The EU now borrows in its own name on a scale the UK always opposed as a member. Repayments run to 2058.

European Commission, NextGenerationEU

0.2%

Germany's growth since 2019

The EU's biggest economy, inside the single market and customs union throughout, has barely grown in six years.

IMF, April 2026

Since 2024

Border checks inside Schengen

Germany brought back checks on all its land borders in 2024 and has kept extending them, inside the passport-free zone a returning UK would have to join.

German Federal Government

27 vetoes

Hard to reform

Changing the EU's treaties needs every member to agree. Hoping to rejoin a reformed EU means waiting for 27 governments to agree on what reform means.

Treaty on European Union, Art. 48

None of this means Europe's voters are wrong. It means the EU a returning UK would enter is more divided, more indebted and slower-growing than the one it left. Joining the slowest-growing group of large economies is an odd plan for faster growth.

The mandate question

Nobody has voted to go back

In Britain's system a prime minister does not need a personal mandate, and Parliament could in law vote to apply. But a change this large has always rested on the voters' consent, and so far nobody has asked for it.

"Britain will stay outside of the EU."

What every Labour MP was elected on

Labour's 2024 manifesto added: "There will be no return to the single market, the customs union, or freedom of movement."

Labour Party manifesto, 2024

33.7%

Labour's share of the vote in 2024

The lowest share on record for a governing party, won on a promise to stay out.

House of Commons Library

379 MPs

Who chose the Prime Minister

Andy Burnham took office on 20 July 2026 after 379 Labour MPs nominated him unopposed. He has not led his party into a general election.

Labour Party leadership election, July 2026

17.4 million

The last time the public was asked

In 2016 more people voted to leave the EU than have ever voted for anything else in Britain. No vote since has reversed it.

Electoral Commission

In fairness: the Prime Minister has said he will set out options and is not expected to act before the next election. He has said Labour's next manifesto could include a referendum. Asked on 30 September 2026 whether he might go ahead without one, he said: "I wouldn't rule anything out at this moment." Sources

Two former Remain Prime Ministers urge caution. Tony Blair says Britain should not rejoin the EU as it stands, and should strengthen its own economy first (The Independent, 12 November 2026). David Cameron, who led the 2016 Remain campaign, also warns against going back. He says reopening the question would be a "very long and painful argument", and that Britain's economic problems "have nothing to do with Brexit". (Bloomberg interview, reported 11 to 12 November 2026.) The reset and the rejoin debate

The red lines were built to end the argument. Chris Ward, Labour MP and co-author of the 2024 manifesto's EU red lines, now writes that they were "designed precisely to close down the debate". He says they "no longer speak to the world as it is in 2026" and should be retired. The promise every Labour MP stood on is being openly questioned by one of the people who wrote it. (The Guardian, as reported by the Daily Express, 10 November 2026.)

Common questions

Rejoining the EU: straight answers

How much would the UK pay if it rejoined the EU?

No official figure exists. In 2020 the UK paid £17.0bn gross after its rebate and £12.6bn net. A re-joining UK would have no rebate and would pay into a larger EU budget, proposed at almost €2 trillion for 2028–2034, and share the repayment of EU recovery-fund debt until 2058. This site uses a scenario range of £20–40bn a year gross. Britain Unbound estimates the bill at £35bn a year from 2028 (July 2026). Stay Out puts the gross bill at £39bn in 2028, about £750m a week (The Spectator, 13 November 2026). Both are campaign groups' projections. Stay Out's research head, Oliver Lewis, who produced Vote Leave's 2016 figures, says the EU Britain would rejoin is "more indebted, divided and expensive than the one we left". If the Commission's proposed new EU charges are not agreed, Stay Out puts the bill higher still, at about £803m a week.

What hidden liabilities would the UK take on?

Beyond the yearly bill, a member state stands behind the EU's borrowing, guarantees and long-term spending commitments. Bob Lyddon of Lyddon Consulting estimates that rejoining would add about £1 trillion of these "shadow" liabilities to the UK, around 34% of GDP, mainly because the UK would share liability for the EU's debts from the day it joined. That would sit on top of public sector net debt of about £3 trillion. It is an independent analyst's estimate based on the EU's proposed 2028–2034 budget, not an official figure (Lyddon Consulting, 1 October 2026).

Would the UK have to join the euro if it rejoined?

New EU members are legally committed to adopt the euro once they meet the entry criteria (Article 140 TFEU). The UK's old opt-out (Protocol 15) would not return automatically, and no new member has been granted a permanent opt-out since 1992.

Would the UK get its budget rebate back?

Not automatically. The UK rebate ended when the UK left. Any new correction would need the unanimous agreement of all 27 existing members.

Would the UK keep the pound if it rejoined?

Not permanently. New EU members commit to adopting the euro once they meet the entry tests. Interest rates would then be set by the European Central Bank for all 21 euro countries, not by the Bank of England.

Do most people in Britain want to rejoin the EU?

Headline polls show about 55% in favour. But when YouGov asked in June 2026 about rejoining without the UK's old opt-outs from the euro and passport-free travel, support fell to 35% and 43% were opposed. The old terms are not on offer: President Macron said in September 2026 that the UK could not pick and choose.

Does the Prime Minister have a mandate to take Britain back into the EU?

Not from voters. Labour's 2024 manifesto said "Britain will stay outside of the EU" and ruled out the single market, the customs union and free movement. Labour won 33.7% of the vote on that promise. Andy Burnham became Prime Minister on 20 July 2026 after being nominated by 379 Labour MPs and has not fought a general election as leader. He has said the next manifesto could include a referendum.

See all the questions

Know someone who thinks Brexit failed?

Send them the facts. Every figure on this page links to its source.